{ "answerability": "evidence_backed_claims_available", "claims": [ { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-start-topology", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-start-topology" ], "predicate": "described_route_connector", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-kennedy-lake", "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir" ], "subject_id": "route-segment-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-start", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "distance_miles": 0.5, "distance_status": "reported", "end_node_id": "route-node-emigrant-kennedy-trail-start", "route_role": "official_mainline", "start_node_id": "trailhead-emigrant-kennedy-meadows", "support": "Traveler 2023 p10 Relief Reservoir entry explicitly places the trail start at the south end of the main road, half a mile from the Kennedy trailhead parking lot. The connecting walk is described but its geometry is not reviewed." } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-start-topology", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-start-topology", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-start-topology", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "Traveler 2023 p10 Relief Reservoir entry explicitly places the trail start at the south end of the main road, half a mile from the Kennedy trailhead parking lot. The connecting walk is described but its geometry is not reviewed. The reported half-mile connecting walk is retained; destination totals are not inferred.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-start-topology", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-traveler-2023" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/sites/nfs/files/legacy-media/stanislaus/Traveler%202023.pdf", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-traveler-2023" } ], "subject": { "entity_id": "route-segment-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-start", "kind": "route_segment", "name": "Kennedy Parking Start" } }, { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-relief-stock-use", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-relief-stock-use" ], "predicate": "historical_trail_use", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir" ], "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "current_condition": "unknown", "reported_use": "heavy stock use", "source_edition": "2018-11" } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-relief-stock-use", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-northern-relief-stock-use", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-relief-stock-use", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "ROG 16-41 November 2018 p2 Relief Reservoir description reports heavy stock use. This is a historical usage report, not current trail suitability.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-relief-stock-use", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-favorite-hikes" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/sites/nfs/files/r05/stanislaus/publication/Favorite%20Hiking%20Trails.pdf", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-favorite-hikes" } ], "subject": { "entity_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "kind": "route", "name": "Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir" } }, { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-start-junction-topology", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-start-junction-topology" ], "predicate": "mapped_route_connector", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-kennedy-lake", "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir" ], "subject_id": "route-segment-emigrant-northern-kennedy-start-junction", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "distance_miles": null, "distance_status": "not_printed", "end_node_id": "route-node-emigrant-kennedy-lake-junction", "route_role": "official_mainline", "start_node_id": "route-node-emigrant-kennedy-trail-start", "support": "2010 overview northern panel shows the trail south from Kennedy Meadows over the footbridges on Huckleberry Trail 20E11 to the named Kennedy Lake Trail 21E03 branch." } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-start-junction-topology", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-start-junction-topology", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-start-junction-topology", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "2010 overview northern panel shows the trail south from Kennedy Meadows over the footbridges on Huckleberry Trail 20E11 to the named Kennedy Lake Trail 21E03 branch. Atomic mileage remains unknown; cumulative reports and GIS lengths are not subtracted or measured.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-start-junction-topology", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-overview-map" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/sites/nfs/files/legacy-media/stanislaus/Emigrant%20Wilderness%20GEOSPATIAL.pdf", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-overview-map" } ], "subject": { "entity_id": "route-segment-emigrant-northern-kennedy-start-junction", "kind": "route_segment", "name": "Kennedy Start Junction" } }, { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-relief-approach-topology", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-relief-approach-topology" ], "predicate": "mapped_route_connector", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir" ], "subject_id": "route-segment-emigrant-northern-relief-approach", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "distance_miles": null, "distance_status": "not_printed", "end_node_id": "route-node-emigrant-relief-east-approach", "route_role": "official_mainline", "start_node_id": "route-node-emigrant-kennedy-lake-junction", "support": "2010 overview northern panel draws 20E11 south past the Kennedy Lake branch along the east side of Relief Reservoir. The selected endpoint is an eastern mainline approach; no shoreline spur is asserted." } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-relief-approach-topology", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-northern-relief-approach-topology", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-relief-approach-topology", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "2010 overview northern panel draws 20E11 south past the Kennedy Lake branch along the east side of Relief Reservoir. The selected endpoint is an eastern mainline approach; no shoreline spur is asserted. Atomic mileage remains unknown; cumulative reports and GIS lengths are not subtracted or measured.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-relief-approach-topology", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-overview-map" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/sites/nfs/files/legacy-media/stanislaus/Emigrant%20Wilderness%20GEOSPATIAL.pdf", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-overview-map" } ], "subject": { "entity_id": "route-segment-emigrant-northern-relief-approach", "kind": "route_segment", "name": "Relief Approach" } }, { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-wilderness-context", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-wilderness-context" ], "predicate": "mapped_wilderness_traversal_context", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-emigrant-wilderness" ], "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "other_jurisdiction_permission": "not established", "whole_route_containment": false, "wilderness_id": "wilderness-emigrant" } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-wilderness-context", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-wilderness-context", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-wilderness-context", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "2010 overview shows this selected approach entering or following Emigrant Wilderness. Sonora PCT follows a jurisdictional divide; Emigrant context does not resolve Hoover permission.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-wilderness-context", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-overview-map" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/sites/nfs/files/legacy-media/stanislaus/Emigrant%20Wilderness%20GEOSPATIAL.pdf", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-overview-map" } ], "subject": { "entity_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "kind": "route", "name": "Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir" } }, { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions" ], "predicate": "pretrip_current_conditions_recheck", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir" ], "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "current_status": "unknown", "required": true, "topics": [ "access roads", "trail and crossings", "water", "fire restrictions", "snow and closures" ] } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "Check current Forest Service orders and conditions against the selected access and intended itinerary. Historical map connections do not establish current crossings, snow, water, fire restrictions or trail clearance.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-alerts" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/r05/stanislaus/alerts", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-alerts" } ], "subject": { "entity_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "kind": "route", "name": "Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir" } }, { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-favorite-hikes", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-favorite-hikes" ], "predicate": "published_approach_distance_report", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir" ], "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "distance_convention": "one way", "endpoint_precision": "unspecified", "not_atomic_distance": true, "reported_miles": 3, "source_edition": "2018-11" } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-favorite-hikes", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-favorite-hikes", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-favorite-hikes", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "2018-11 favorite-hikes: Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir is reported as 3 miles (one way). Precise endpoint and parking inclusion are not resolved.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-favorite-hikes", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-favorite-hikes" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/sites/nfs/files/r05/stanislaus/publication/Favorite%20Hiking%20Trails.pdf", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-favorite-hikes" } ], "subject": { "entity_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "kind": "route", "name": "Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir" } }, { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-mileage-table", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-mileage-table" ], "predicate": "published_approach_distance_report", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir" ], "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "distance_convention": "one way", "endpoint_precision": "unspecified", "not_atomic_distance": true, "reported_miles": 3, "source_edition": "2012-06" } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-mileage-table", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-mileage-table", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-mileage-table", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "2012-06 mileage-table: Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir is reported as 3 miles (one way). Precise endpoint and parking inclusion are not resolved.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-mileage-table", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-mileage-table" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/sites/nfs/files/legacy-media/stanislaus/Trail%20Mileages%20-%20Emigrant%202012.pdf", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-mileage-table" } ], "subject": { "entity_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "kind": "route", "name": "Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir" } }, { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023" ], "predicate": "published_approach_distance_report", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir" ], "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "distance_convention": "round trip", "endpoint_precision": "unspecified", "not_atomic_distance": true, "reported_miles": 6, "source_edition": "2023" } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "2023 traveler-2023: Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir is reported as 6 miles (round trip). Precise endpoint and parking inclusion are not resolved.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-traveler-2023" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/sites/nfs/files/legacy-media/stanislaus/Traveler%202023.pdf", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-traveler-2023" } ], "subject": { "entity_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "kind": "route", "name": "Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir" } }, { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance" ], "predicate": "reported_access_walk_distance", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir" ], "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "from": "trailhead parking lot", "inclusion_in_destination_total": "unknown", "not_added_to_destination_reports": true, "reported_miles": 0.5, "to": "trail start at south end of main road" } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "Traveler 2023 p10 states that the trail begins half a mile from the parking lot, at the south end of the main road. It does not state whether the six-mile round-trip destination total includes this connection.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-traveler-2023" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/sites/nfs/files/legacy-media/stanislaus/Traveler%202023.pdf", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-traveler-2023" } ], "subject": { "entity_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "kind": "route", "name": "Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir" } }, { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile" ], "predicate": "route_description", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir" ], "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "current_conditions": "unknown", "directionality": "bidirectional mapped trail", "display_geometry": "not reviewed", "end_node_id": "route-node-emigrant-relief-east-approach", "endpoint_status": "trail approach; not campsite or resource centroid", "entry_id": "trailhead-emigrant-kennedy-meadows", "name_status": "Wayproof descriptive approach", "objective_id": "waterbody-emigrant-relief-reservoir", "source_edition": "2010" } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "2010 Emigrant map northern panel explicitly draws the selected named trails. Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir is a Wayproof descriptive approach, not an official named itinerary. Kennedy parking connection is separately supported by Traveler 2023; the Eagle approach stops at the northern side of the boundary pass.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-overview-map" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/sites/nfs/files/legacy-media/stanislaus/Emigrant%20Wilderness%20GEOSPATIAL.pdf", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-overview-map" } ], "subject": { "entity_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "kind": "route", "name": "Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir" } } ], "entity": { "entity_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "kind": "route", "name": "Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir" }, "gap_details": [ { "claims": [ { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions" ], "predicate": "pretrip_current_conditions_recheck", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir" ], "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "current_status": "unknown", "required": true, "topics": [ "access roads", "trail and crossings", "water", "fire restrictions", "snow and closures" ] } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "Check current Forest Service orders and conditions against the selected access and intended itinerary. Historical map connections do not establish current crossings, snow, water, fire restrictions or trail clearance.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-alerts" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/r05/stanislaus/alerts", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-alerts" } ] }, { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile" ], "predicate": "route_description", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir" ], "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "current_conditions": "unknown", "directionality": "bidirectional mapped trail", "display_geometry": "not reviewed", "end_node_id": "route-node-emigrant-relief-east-approach", "endpoint_status": "trail approach; not campsite or resource centroid", "entry_id": "trailhead-emigrant-kennedy-meadows", "name_status": "Wayproof descriptive approach", "objective_id": "waterbody-emigrant-relief-reservoir", "source_edition": "2010" } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "2010 Emigrant map northern panel explicitly draws the selected named trails. Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir is a Wayproof descriptive approach, not an official named itinerary. Kennedy parking connection is separately supported by Traveler 2023; the Eagle approach stops at the northern side of the boundary pass.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-overview-map" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/sites/nfs/files/legacy-media/stanislaus/Emigrant%20Wilderness%20GEOSPATIAL.pdf", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-overview-map" } ] } ], "entities": [ { "entity_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "kind": "route", "name": "Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir" } ], "history": [ { "action": "ADD", "change_set_id": "wp-20261006-emigrant-northern-coverage", "evidence_refs": [], "knowledge_gap_refs": [ "gap-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-planning" ], "path": "canonical/v0/gaps/gap-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-planning.json", "reason": "Add bounded northern approaches, geometry and historical access evidence; preserve unresolved planning limits.", "record_id": "gap-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-planning", "record_type": "gap", "summary": "Add six northern Emigrant approaches, four with reviewed display geometry, plus distinct historical facilities and access conflicts." } ], "navigation": { "next_id": "gap-emigrant-northern-kennedy-mileage-basis", "position": 189, "previous_id": "gap-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-operator", "total": 299 }, "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "Check current Forest Service orders and conditions against the selected access and intended itinerary. Historical map connections do not establish current crossings, snow, water, fire restrictions or trail clearance.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-alerts" }, { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "2010 Emigrant map northern panel explicitly draws the selected named trails. Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir is a Wayproof descriptive approach, not an official named itinerary. Kennedy parking connection is separately supported by Traveler 2023; the Eagle approach stops at the northern side of the boundary pass.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-overview-map" } ], "record": { "gap_id": "gap-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-planning", "question": "What remains unverified for Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir?", "reason": "The selected approach has a sourced bidirectional graph; atomic mileage, return itinerary, shoreline paths, individual campsites and current conditions remain unknown. Source destination mileages may refer to a different precise endpoint. No display geometry is published: the parking-to-trail connection is unreviewed and the Kennedy Lake branch has an unsnapped roughly 45-metre source offset. The graph comes from explicit map/guide connections, not coordinate proximity.", "related_ids": [ "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile", "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions" ] }, "record_type": "gap", "related_records": [ { "record": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile" ], "predicate": "route_description", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir" ], "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "current_conditions": "unknown", "directionality": "bidirectional mapped trail", "display_geometry": "not reviewed", "end_node_id": "route-node-emigrant-relief-east-approach", "endpoint_status": "trail approach; not campsite or resource centroid", "entry_id": "trailhead-emigrant-kennedy-meadows", "name_status": "Wayproof descriptive approach", "objective_id": "waterbody-emigrant-relief-reservoir", "source_edition": "2010" } }, "record_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile", "record_type": "claim" }, { "record": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions" ], "predicate": "pretrip_current_conditions_recheck", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir" ], "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "current_status": "unknown", "required": true, "topics": [ "access roads", "trail and crossings", "water", "fire restrictions", "snow and closures" ] } }, "record_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions", "record_type": "claim" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/r05/stanislaus/alerts", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-alerts" }, { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/sites/nfs/files/legacy-media/stanislaus/Emigrant%20Wilderness%20GEOSPATIAL.pdf", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-overview-map" } ] }, { "claims": [ { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-kennedy-lake-mileage-mileage-table", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-kennedy-lake-mileage-mileage-table" ], "predicate": "published_approach_distance_report", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-kennedy-lake" ], "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-kennedy-lake", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "distance_convention": "one way", "endpoint_precision": "unspecified", "not_atomic_distance": true, "reported_miles": 7.5, "source_edition": "2012-06" } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-kennedy-lake-mileage-mileage-table", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-kennedy-lake-mileage-mileage-table", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-kennedy-lake-mileage-mileage-table", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "2012-06 mileage-table: Kennedy Meadows to Kennedy Lake is reported as 7.5 miles (one way). Precise endpoint and parking inclusion are not resolved.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-kennedy-lake-mileage-mileage-table", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-mileage-table" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/sites/nfs/files/legacy-media/stanislaus/Trail%20Mileages%20-%20Emigrant%202012.pdf", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-mileage-table" } ] }, { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023" ], "predicate": "published_approach_distance_report", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir" ], "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "distance_convention": "round trip", "endpoint_precision": "unspecified", "not_atomic_distance": true, "reported_miles": 6, "source_edition": "2023" } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "2023 traveler-2023: Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir is reported as 6 miles (round trip). Precise endpoint and parking inclusion are not resolved.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-traveler-2023" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/sites/nfs/files/legacy-media/stanislaus/Traveler%202023.pdf", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-traveler-2023" } ] }, { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance" ], "predicate": "reported_access_walk_distance", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir" ], "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "from": "trailhead parking lot", "inclusion_in_destination_total": "unknown", "not_added_to_destination_reports": true, "reported_miles": 0.5, "to": "trail start at south end of main road" } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "Traveler 2023 p10 states that the trail begins half a mile from the parking lot, at the south end of the main road. It does not state whether the six-mile round-trip destination total includes this connection.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-traveler-2023" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/sites/nfs/files/legacy-media/stanislaus/Traveler%202023.pdf", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-traveler-2023" } ] } ], "entities": [ { "entity_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-kennedy-lake", "kind": "route", "name": "Kennedy Meadows to Kennedy Lake" }, { "entity_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "kind": "route", "name": "Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir" } ], "history": [ { "action": "ADD", "change_set_id": "wp-20261006-emigrant-northern-coverage", "evidence_refs": [], "knowledge_gap_refs": [ "gap-emigrant-northern-kennedy-mileage-basis" ], "path": "canonical/v0/gaps/gap-emigrant-northern-kennedy-mileage-basis.json", "reason": "Add bounded northern approaches, geometry and historical access evidence; preserve unresolved planning limits.", "record_id": "gap-emigrant-northern-kennedy-mileage-basis", "record_type": "gap", "summary": "Add six northern Emigrant approaches, four with reviewed display geometry, plus distinct historical facilities and access conflicts." } ], "navigation": { "next_id": "gap-emigrant-northern-sonora-pass-access", "position": 190, "previous_id": "gap-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-planning", "total": 299 }, "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "2012-06 mileage-table: Kennedy Meadows to Kennedy Lake is reported as 7.5 miles (one way). Precise endpoint and parking inclusion are not resolved.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-kennedy-lake-mileage-mileage-table", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-mileage-table" }, { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "2023 traveler-2023: Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir is reported as 6 miles (round trip). Precise endpoint and parking inclusion are not resolved.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-traveler-2023" }, { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "Traveler 2023 p10 states that the trail begins half a mile from the parking lot, at the south end of the main road. It does not state whether the six-mile round-trip destination total includes this connection.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-traveler-2023" } ], "record": { "gap_id": "gap-emigrant-northern-kennedy-mileage-basis", "question": "Do Kennedy approach totals include the walk from parking?", "reason": "The 2023 guide gives a six-mile round trip and a separate half-mile parking-to-trail walk; the 2012/2018 reports give three miles one way. Kennedy Lake is reported as 7.5 miles by the 2012 table and an undated riding operator. No arithmetic resolves parking inclusion or precise endpoint. Confirm intended start before using these reports.", "related_ids": [ "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance", "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023", "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-kennedy-lake-mileage-mileage-table" ] }, "record_type": "gap", "related_records": [ { "record": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance" ], "predicate": "reported_access_walk_distance", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir" ], "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "from": "trailhead parking lot", "inclusion_in_destination_total": "unknown", "not_added_to_destination_reports": true, "reported_miles": 0.5, "to": "trail start at south end of main road" } }, "record_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance", "record_type": "claim" }, { "record": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023" ], "predicate": "published_approach_distance_report", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir" ], "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "distance_convention": "round trip", "endpoint_precision": "unspecified", "not_atomic_distance": true, "reported_miles": 6, "source_edition": "2023" } }, "record_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023", "record_type": "claim" }, { "record": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-kennedy-lake-mileage-mileage-table", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-kennedy-lake-mileage-mileage-table" ], "predicate": "published_approach_distance_report", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-kennedy-lake" ], "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-kennedy-lake", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "distance_convention": "one way", "endpoint_precision": "unspecified", "not_atomic_distance": true, "reported_miles": 7.5, "source_edition": "2012-06" } }, "record_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-kennedy-lake-mileage-mileage-table", "record_type": "claim" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/sites/nfs/files/legacy-media/stanislaus/Trail%20Mileages%20-%20Emigrant%202012.pdf", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-mileage-table" }, { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/sites/nfs/files/legacy-media/stanislaus/Traveler%202023.pdf", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-traveler-2023" } ] } ], "history": [ { "action": "ADD", "change_set_id": "wp-20261006-emigrant-northern-coverage", "evidence_refs": [], "knowledge_gap_refs": [], "path": "canonical/v0/entities/route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir.json", "reason": "Add bounded northern approaches, geometry and historical access evidence; preserve unresolved planning limits.", "record_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "record_type": "entity", "summary": "Add six northern Emigrant approaches, four with reviewed display geometry, plus distinct historical facilities and access conflicts." }, { "action": "ADD", "change_set_id": "wp-20261006-emigrant-northern-coverage", "evidence_refs": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-start-topology" ], "knowledge_gap_refs": [], "path": "canonical/v0/claims/claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-start-topology.json", "reason": "Add bounded northern approaches, geometry and historical access evidence; preserve unresolved planning limits.", "record_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-start-topology", "record_type": "claim", "summary": "Add six northern Emigrant approaches, four with reviewed display geometry, plus distinct historical facilities and access conflicts." }, { "action": "ADD", "change_set_id": "wp-20261006-emigrant-northern-coverage", "evidence_refs": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-relief-stock-use" ], "knowledge_gap_refs": [], "path": "canonical/v0/claims/claim-emigrant-northern-relief-stock-use.json", "reason": "Add bounded northern approaches, geometry and historical access evidence; preserve unresolved planning limits.", "record_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-relief-stock-use", "record_type": "claim", "summary": "Add six northern Emigrant approaches, four with reviewed display geometry, plus distinct historical facilities and access conflicts." }, { "action": "ADD", "change_set_id": "wp-20261006-emigrant-northern-coverage", "evidence_refs": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-start-junction-topology" ], "knowledge_gap_refs": [], "path": "canonical/v0/claims/claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-start-junction-topology.json", "reason": "Add bounded northern approaches, geometry and historical access evidence; preserve unresolved planning limits.", "record_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-start-junction-topology", "record_type": "claim", "summary": "Add six northern Emigrant approaches, four with reviewed display geometry, plus distinct historical facilities and access conflicts." }, { "action": "ADD", "change_set_id": "wp-20261006-emigrant-northern-coverage", "evidence_refs": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-relief-approach-topology" ], "knowledge_gap_refs": [], "path": "canonical/v0/claims/claim-emigrant-northern-relief-approach-topology.json", "reason": "Add bounded northern approaches, geometry and historical access evidence; preserve unresolved planning limits.", "record_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-relief-approach-topology", "record_type": "claim", "summary": "Add six northern Emigrant approaches, four with reviewed display geometry, plus distinct historical facilities and access conflicts." }, { "action": "ADD", "change_set_id": "wp-20261006-emigrant-northern-coverage", "evidence_refs": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-wilderness-context" ], "knowledge_gap_refs": [], "path": "canonical/v0/claims/claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-wilderness-context.json", "reason": "Add bounded northern approaches, geometry and historical access evidence; preserve unresolved planning limits.", "record_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-wilderness-context", "record_type": "claim", "summary": "Add six northern Emigrant approaches, four with reviewed display geometry, plus distinct historical facilities and access conflicts." }, { "action": "ADD", "change_set_id": "wp-20261006-emigrant-northern-coverage", "evidence_refs": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions" ], "knowledge_gap_refs": [], "path": "canonical/v0/claims/claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions.json", "reason": "Add bounded northern approaches, geometry and historical access evidence; preserve unresolved planning limits.", "record_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions", "record_type": "claim", "summary": "Add six northern Emigrant approaches, four with reviewed display geometry, plus distinct historical facilities and access conflicts." }, { "action": "ADD", "change_set_id": "wp-20261006-emigrant-northern-coverage", "evidence_refs": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-favorite-hikes" ], "knowledge_gap_refs": [], "path": "canonical/v0/claims/claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-favorite-hikes.json", "reason": "Add bounded northern approaches, geometry and historical access evidence; preserve unresolved planning limits.", "record_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-favorite-hikes", "record_type": "claim", "summary": "Add six northern Emigrant approaches, four with reviewed display geometry, plus distinct historical facilities and access conflicts." }, { "action": "ADD", "change_set_id": "wp-20261006-emigrant-northern-coverage", "evidence_refs": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-mileage-table" ], "knowledge_gap_refs": [], "path": "canonical/v0/claims/claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-mileage-table.json", "reason": "Add bounded northern approaches, geometry and historical access evidence; preserve unresolved planning limits.", "record_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-mileage-table", "record_type": "claim", "summary": "Add six northern Emigrant approaches, four with reviewed display geometry, plus distinct historical facilities and access conflicts." }, { "action": "ADD", "change_set_id": "wp-20261006-emigrant-northern-coverage", "evidence_refs": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023" ], "knowledge_gap_refs": [], "path": "canonical/v0/claims/claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023.json", "reason": "Add bounded northern approaches, geometry and historical access evidence; preserve unresolved planning limits.", "record_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023", "record_type": "claim", "summary": "Add six northern Emigrant approaches, four with reviewed display geometry, plus distinct historical facilities and access conflicts." }, { "action": "ADD", "change_set_id": "wp-20261006-emigrant-northern-coverage", "evidence_refs": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance" ], "knowledge_gap_refs": [], "path": "canonical/v0/claims/claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance.json", "reason": "Add bounded northern approaches, geometry and historical access evidence; preserve unresolved planning limits.", "record_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance", "record_type": "claim", "summary": "Add six northern Emigrant approaches, four with reviewed display geometry, plus distinct historical facilities and access conflicts." }, { "action": "ADD", "change_set_id": "wp-20261006-emigrant-northern-coverage", "evidence_refs": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile" ], "knowledge_gap_refs": [], "path": "canonical/v0/claims/claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile.json", "reason": "Add bounded northern approaches, geometry and historical access evidence; preserve unresolved planning limits.", "record_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile", "record_type": "claim", "summary": "Add six northern Emigrant approaches, four with reviewed display geometry, plus distinct historical facilities and access conflicts." } ], "journey": [ { "claims": [ { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions" ], "predicate": "pretrip_current_conditions_recheck", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir" ], "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "current_status": "unknown", "required": true, "topics": [ "access roads", "trail and crossings", "water", "fire restrictions", "snow and closures" ] } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "Check current Forest Service orders and conditions against the selected access and intended itinerary. Historical map connections do not establish current crossings, snow, water, fire restrictions or trail clearance.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source text, geospatial map and named-feature review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-06T15:34:28+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-alerts" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/r05/stanislaus/alerts", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-alerts" } ], "subject": { "entity_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "kind": "route", "name": "Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir" } } ], "entity": { "entity_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "kind": "route", "name": "Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir" }, "gaps": [ { "gap_id": "gap-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-planning", "question": "What remains unverified for Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir?", "reason": "The selected approach has a sourced bidirectional graph; atomic mileage, return itinerary, shoreline paths, individual campsites and current conditions remain unknown. Source destination mileages may refer to a different precise endpoint. No display geometry is published: the parking-to-trail connection is unreviewed and the Kennedy Lake branch has an unsnapped roughly 45-metre source offset. The graph comes from explicit map/guide connections, not coordinate proximity.", "related_ids": [ "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile", "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions" ] } ], "relationships": [], "role": "Selected place" }, { "claims": [ { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-kennedy-meadows", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-approach-recheck-kennedy-meadows" ], "predicate": "pretrip_current_conditions_recheck", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-emigrant-kennedy-meadows" ], "subject_id": "trailhead-emigrant-kennedy-meadows", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "required": true, "status": "unknown", "topics": [ "road and trail status", "fire restrictions", "parking and facility availability" ] } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-kennedy-meadows", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-approach-recheck-kennedy-meadows", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-approach-recheck-kennedy-meadows", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "The forest alert index contains dynamic road and fire orders. Current applicability to Kennedy Meadows Trailhead (Stanislaus) needs individual order and map review; its named access relationship is not an open-status observation.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-approach-recheck-kennedy-meadows", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-05T22:09:18+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-alerts" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/r05/stanislaus/alerts", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-alerts" } ], "subject": { "entity_id": "trailhead-emigrant-kennedy-meadows", "kind": "trailhead", "name": "Kennedy Meadows Trailhead (Stanislaus)" } } ], "entity": { "entity_id": "trailhead-emigrant-kennedy-meadows", "kind": "trailhead", "name": "Kennedy Meadows Trailhead (Stanislaus)" }, "gaps": [ { "gap_id": "gap-emigrant-current-conditions", "question": "Are the selected approach and facilities usable on the trip date?", "reason": "Current road, trail, snow, crossing, water, fire and facility status is unknown. Individual alerts and mapped closures need route-specific matching; the Site Open banner is not route-level clearance.", "related_ids": [ "wilderness-emigrant", "claim-emigrant-conditions-recheck", "claim-emigrant-alerts-recheck", "claim-emigrant-access-recheck", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-bell-meadow", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-bourland-meadow", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-box-springs", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-crabtree", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-coyote-meadow", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-eagle-meadow", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-gianelli", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-kennedy-meadows", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-waterhouse", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-sonora-pass" ] } ], "relationships": [ { "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile" ], "object_id": "trailhead-emigrant-kennedy-meadows", "predicate": "starts_at", "relationship_id": "relationship-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-start", "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null } ], "role": "Entry" }, { "claims": [ { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-dogs", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-dogs" ], "predicate": "pet_policy", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-emigrant-wilderness" ], "subject_id": "wilderness-emigrant", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "county_leash_ordinance": "Tuolumne County; verify details", "direct_control_required": true } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-dogs", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-dogs", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-dogs", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "Pet Information: dogs must be under direct control and Tuolumne County has a leash ordinance.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-dogs", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-05T22:09:18+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-access" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/r05/stanislaus/recreation/emigrant-wilderness-highway-108-access", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-access" } ], "subject": { "entity_id": "wilderness-emigrant", "kind": "wilderness", "name": "Emigrant Wilderness" } }, { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-access-recheck", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-access-recheck" ], "predicate": "pretrip_current_conditions_recheck", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-emigrant-wilderness" ], "subject_id": "wilderness-emigrant", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "required": true, "topics": [ "access roads", "parking", "trail conditions", "water and facilities", "issuing station operations" ] } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-access-recheck", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-access-recheck", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-access-recheck", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "Operational Hours directs visitors to check conditions and weather before travel; named access points do not establish that a road, parking space, water supply or facility will be available.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-access-recheck", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-05T22:09:18+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-access" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/r05/stanislaus/recreation/emigrant-wilderness-highway-108-access", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-access" } ], "subject": { "entity_id": "wilderness-emigrant", "kind": "wilderness", "name": "Emigrant Wilderness" } }, { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-alerts-recheck", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-alerts-recheck" ], "predicate": "pretrip_current_conditions_recheck", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-emigrant-wilderness" ], "subject_id": "wilderness-emigrant", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "current_route_access": "unknown", "required": true, "topics": [ "road closures and seasonal access", "current fire orders", "occupancy rules" ] } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-alerts-recheck", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-alerts-recheck", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-alerts-recheck", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "Alerts index reviewed October 5, 2026 includes fire restrictions, occupancy limits and road closure orders, including a portion of 4N12 and Cherry access road 1N98. Exact applicability and current status require individual order/map review.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-alerts-recheck", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-05T22:09:18+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-alerts" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/r05/stanislaus/alerts", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-alerts" } ], "subject": { "entity_id": "wilderness-emigrant", "kind": "wilderness", "name": "Emigrant Wilderness" } }, { "claim": { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-conditions-recheck", "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-conditions-recheck" ], "predicate": "pretrip_current_conditions_recheck", "spatial_scope_ids": [ "scope-emigrant-wilderness" ], "subject_id": "wilderness-emigrant", "temporal_scope": null, "value": { "required": true, "topics": [ "fire restrictions", "smoke", "snow", "weather and avalanche conditions" ] } }, "evidence": [ { "claim_id": "claim-emigrant-conditions-recheck", "evidence_id": "evidence-emigrant-conditions-recheck", "notes": "", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-conditions-recheck", "stance": "supports" } ], "observations": [ { "artifact_refs": [], "content": "Current Conditions links to current fire restrictions, fire/smoke, avalanche forecasts and regional snow depth. These are pre-trip checking sources, not an observation of open roads or safe trails.", "observation_id": "observation-emigrant-conditions-recheck", "observed_at": null, "observer": "Wayproof primary-source review", "retrieved_at": "2026-10-05T22:09:18+00:00", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-conditions" } ], "sources": [ { "locator": "https://www.fs.usda.gov/r05/stanislaus/conditions", "publisher": "USDA Forest Service, Stanislaus National Forest", "source_id": "source-usfs-emigrant-conditions" } ], "subject": { "entity_id": "wilderness-emigrant", "kind": "wilderness", "name": "Emigrant Wilderness" } } ], "entity": { "entity_id": "wilderness-emigrant", "kind": "wilderness", "name": "Emigrant Wilderness" }, "gaps": [ { "gap_id": "gap-emigrant-current-conditions", "question": "Are the selected approach and facilities usable on the trip date?", "reason": "Current road, trail, snow, crossing, water, fire and facility status is unknown. Individual alerts and mapped closures need route-specific matching; the Site Open banner is not route-level clearance.", "related_ids": [ "wilderness-emigrant", "claim-emigrant-conditions-recheck", "claim-emigrant-alerts-recheck", "claim-emigrant-access-recheck", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-bell-meadow", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-bourland-meadow", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-box-springs", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-crabtree", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-coyote-meadow", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-eagle-meadow", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-gianelli", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-kennedy-meadows", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-waterhouse", "claim-emigrant-approach-recheck-sonora-pass" ] }, { "gap_id": "gap-emigrant-route-topology", "question": "How do the selected trailheads connect to lakes, passes and each other?", "reason": "The eight western approaches from Crabtree, Gianelli, Bell Meadow and six northern approaches are joined by five bounded southern/eastern approaches: Box Springs–Chain Lakes, Bourland mapped terminus, Shingle Springs–Kibbie/Huckleberry and Leavitt Lake–PCT junction. Bourland continuation, Kennedy parking/branch geometry, southern display gaps, deeper lake/pass branches, returns and individual facility spurs remain unresolved; no wilderness-wide route completeness is claimed.", "related_ids": [ "wilderness-emigrant", "claim-emigrant-access-recheck" ] }, { "gap_id": "gap-emigrant-boundary-geometry", "question": "What boundary precision and exact jurisdiction remain unverified?", "reason": "Reviewed PAD-US designated-wilderness display geometry now matches Emigrant Wilderness, OBJECTID 237112. Survey/legal precision, current amendments and exact route-side jurisdiction remain unverified. Polygon overlap does not create access, containment or permission.", "related_ids": [ "wilderness-emigrant", "claim-emigrant-access-recheck" ] }, { "gap_id": "gap-emigrant-facility-inventory", "question": "What camps, toilets, water sources and parking are available along the approach?", "reason": "Coverage includes historical trailhead facilities, Baker/Deadman/Cherry Valley campground reports, 45 individually reviewed Cherry Valley listing pages and Kennedy cabin inventory. Conflicting water/toilet/fee reports, omitted Cherry Valley site 001, individual Baker/Deadman sites, current availability, remote camps and facility connectors remain unresolved. Inventory is not a reservation or operating guarantee.", "related_ids": [ "wilderness-emigrant", "claim-emigrant-access-recheck" ] } ], "relationships": [ { "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile" ], "object_id": "wilderness-emigrant", "predicate": "traverses", "relationship_id": "relationship-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-land", "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null } ], "role": "Traversed place" } ], "knowledge_gaps": [ { "gap_id": "gap-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-planning", "question": "What remains unverified for Kennedy Meadows to Relief Reservoir?", "reason": "The selected approach has a sourced bidirectional graph; atomic mileage, return itinerary, shoreline paths, individual campsites and current conditions remain unknown. Source destination mileages may refer to a different precise endpoint. No display geometry is published: the parking-to-trail connection is unreviewed and the Kennedy Lake branch has an unsnapped roughly 45-metre source offset. The graph comes from explicit map/guide connections, not coordinate proximity.", "related_ids": [ "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile", "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-conditions" ] }, { "gap_id": "gap-emigrant-northern-kennedy-mileage-basis", "question": "Do Kennedy approach totals include the walk from parking?", "reason": "The 2023 guide gives a six-mile round trip and a separate half-mile parking-to-trail walk; the 2012/2018 reports give three miles one way. Kennedy Lake is reported as 7.5 miles by the 2012 table and an undated riding operator. No arithmetic resolves parking inclusion or precise endpoint. Confirm intended start before using these reports.", "related_ids": [ "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-distance", "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-mileage-traveler-2023", "claim-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-kennedy-lake-mileage-mileage-table" ] } ], "reference_evidence": [], "relationships": [ { "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile" ], "object_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "predicate": "approached_via", "relationship_id": "relationship-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-objective", "subject_id": "waterbody-emigrant-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null }, { "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile" ], "object_id": "route-node-emigrant-relief-east-approach", "predicate": "ends_at", "relationship_id": "relationship-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-end", "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null }, { "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile" ], "object_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "predicate": "part_of", "relationship_id": "relationship-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-kennedy-parking-start", "subject_id": "route-segment-emigrant-northern-kennedy-parking-start", "temporal_scope": null }, { "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile" ], "object_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "predicate": "part_of", "relationship_id": "relationship-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-kennedy-start-junction", "subject_id": "route-segment-emigrant-northern-kennedy-start-junction", "temporal_scope": null }, { "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile" ], "object_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "predicate": "part_of", "relationship_id": "relationship-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-relief-approach", "subject_id": "route-segment-emigrant-northern-relief-approach", "temporal_scope": null }, { "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile" ], "object_id": "trailhead-emigrant-kennedy-meadows", "predicate": "starts_at", "relationship_id": "relationship-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-start", "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null }, { "evidence_ids": [ "evidence-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-profile" ], "object_id": "wilderness-emigrant", "predicate": "traverses", "relationship_id": "relationship-emigrant-northern-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir-land", "subject_id": "route-emigrant-kennedy-meadows-relief-reservoir", "temporal_scope": null } ], "route_geometry": null, "route_geometry_url": null, "type": "canonical_entity" }